In 16th century Japan, the African slave of a Jesuit priest rises to become a samurai in the service of its most powerful warlord, and faces the challenge of a corrupt general who is scheming to topple the warlord and rule in his place.

3 reviews

dpg Singularity · 112,231 pts

Agree about keeping it simple. Focus on the story hook.

The hook of the story is not the Jesuist priest. ?And it's not having to fend of a competing, corrupt rival (although that's the central conflict). ?The hook, the sizzle in the concept is that a Black man actually rose from slavery to the rank of a samurai in the closed ?and ethnocentric world of Medieval Japan.

The rest is window dressing, detail for the script.

Neer Shelter Singularity · 55,464 pts

The logline describes a vague plot because the inciting incident "...rises to become a samurai..." seams like a long process initiated by the main character rather than a sudden even which changes the MCs life and forces him to take action. It seams like the "real" inciting incident that motivated him to want to become a samurai would have happened before hand, what was it?

The second big problem is the goal is not clear, what does "...the challenge of a corrupt general..." mean specifically? What will it look like? Best to be specific about the goal and what he must achieve?

Lastly what is at stake? What could make this a compelling story is a clear definition of what he stands to lose if he fails and gain if he succeeds.

Hope this helps.

Jaybird1091 Penpusher · 100 pts

If you can simplify further, it'd be a big improvement. Made my head spin a bit. Something more like: "In ancient Japan, a priest's slave becomes a samurai, and fights to defend his warlord against a corrupt general."